Skip to content

Colgate University vs St. John Fisher University

Colgate University is a private university in Hamilton, NY. St. John Fisher University is a private university in Rochester, NY. Colgate University admits about 14% of applicants and St. John Fisher University about 66%, making Colgate University the harder of the two to get into. Students pay an average of about $28,786 a year at Colgate University after aid, and about $28,945 at St. John Fisher University. About 91% of students graduate at Colgate University, compared with 74% at St. John Fisher University. Ten years after enrolling, Colgate University alumni earn a median of about $85,139, against $66,944 for St. John Fisher University.

Colgate University

Hamilton, NY · Private

St. John Fisher University

Rochester, NY · Private
At a glance
Type
Private
Private
Location
Hamilton, NY
Rochester, NY
Setting
Rural
Suburban
Undergraduates
3,180
2,565
Acceptance rate
14%
66%
Admissions
GPA (admitted)
3.5–4
3.49–3.99
SAT (middle 50%)
1430–1540
1120–1300
ACT (middle 50%)
33–34
23–28
Test policy
Test optional
Test optional
Cost
Avg net price / yr
$28,786
$28,945
Full cost / yr
$87,070
$55,201
In-state tuition
$70,306
$41,190
Out-of-state tuition
$70,306
$41,190
Application fee
$60
Not reported
Net price by family income
Family income under $30k
$6,086
$16,054
$30k - $48k
$2,678
$17,953
$48k - $75k
$13,617
$25,992
$75k - $110k
$21,831
$30,268
Over $110k
$48,234
$34,085
Outcomes
Graduation rate
91%
74%
Freshman retention
93%
86%
Median earnings (6 yr)
$64,949
$61,198
Median earnings (10 yr)
$85,139
$66,944
Median debt at graduation
$15,000
$23,250
Student body
Pell grant recipients
13%
29%
First-generation students
18%
25%
International students
8%
0%
Deadlines
Early decision
Nov 1
Dec 1
Early action
Not reported
Dec 1
Regular decision
Jan 15
Rolling

Net price is the average across aided students (U.S. College Scorecard). Your actual cost and admission odds depend on your profile. Take the free Matchmaker for your own numbers.

Frequently asked questions
Is Colgate University or St. John Fisher University harder to get into?
Colgate University is harder to get into. It admits about 14% of applicants, compared with 66% at St. John Fisher University. Your own odds and price depend on your profile, so take Blueprint's free Matchmaker to see your numbers at both.
Which is cheaper, Colgate University or St. John Fisher University?
Colgate University is cheaper on average. Students pay about $28,786 a year after grants and scholarships, against about $28,945 at St. John Fisher University. Your own odds and price depend on your profile, so take Blueprint's free Matchmaker to see your numbers at both.
What is the full cost of attendance at Colgate University and St. John Fisher University?
Before aid, St. John Fisher University costs about $55,201 a year and Colgate University about $87,070. That is the sticker price; most students pay less once grants and scholarships are applied.
Which is cheaper for a family earning under $30,000, Colgate University or St. John Fisher University?
Colgate University. Families earning under $30,000 a year pay about $6,086 there, against about $16,054 at St. John Fisher University. Aid is income-tested, so this can differ from the average price and from the sticker price.
Which is bigger, Colgate University or St. John Fisher University?
Colgate University is the larger of the two, with about 3,180 undergraduates against 2,565 at St. John Fisher University.
Does Colgate University or St. John Fisher University have a better graduation rate?
Colgate University has the higher graduation rate, at about 91% against 74% at St. John Fisher University.
Do graduates of Colgate University or St. John Fisher University earn more?
Colgate University alumni earn more on average: a median of about $85,139 ten years after enrolling, against about $66,944 for St. John Fisher University. Earnings vary far more by major than by school.
Do Colgate University and St. John Fisher University require SAT or ACT scores?
Colgate University is test optional, so scores are considered only if you choose to send them. St. John Fisher University is test optional, so scores are considered only if you choose to send them.
What SAT scores do Colgate University and St. John Fisher University look for?
The middle 50% of admitted students score 1430–1540 at Colgate University and 1120–1300 at St. John Fisher University. A quarter of admitted students scored below those ranges.

Related comparisons

Which of these is the better fit for you?

These lists are a great start, but the one list that actually matters is yours. Blueprint builds it in two free steps.

1 Discovery quiz: find your major2 Matchmaker: your odds + net price at every school